View all publications

Chapter 5: Solvent and other product use

5.1 Sector overview (CRF 3)

This sector includes emissions from chemical cleaning substances used in dry-cleaning, printing, metal degreasing and a variety of industrial and household uses. Also included are emissions from paints, lacquers, thinners and related materials. Emissions arise from the evaporation of the volatile chemicals when solvent-based products are exposed to air.

Solvents and related compounds are a significant source of emissions of NMVOC. Some solvents have been banned under the Montreal Protocol and there is an international trend away from solvent use in paints towards water-based (acrylic) paints.

Emissions from the “solvent and other product use” sector in 2005 comprised 33.9 Gg of NMVOC. This is an increase of 6.2 Gg (18.2 per cent) from 27.7 Gg in 1990. The categories dominating the sector are NMVOC emissions from “paint application” and “other domestic and commercial use” (Figure 5.1.1).

Figure 5.1.1 Emissions of NMVOC from the solvent and other product use sector in 2005 (all figures Gg NMVOC)

 

Category

Gg CO2 equivalent

Percent of total

Paint application

16.6

49.0

Degreasing and drycleaning

0.7

2.1

Chemical products

0.8

2.3

Other

15.8

46.5

In 2005, N2O emissions from anaesthesia use totalled 0.2 Gg N2O or 48.4 Gg CO2-e. This is a small increase from 1990 when emissions from anaesthesia totalled 0.1 Gg N2O.

5.1.1 Description

Ethanol and methanol are the only solvents produced in New Zealand and the majority of both products are exported. All other solvents are imported, including some ethanol and methanol (for quality and price reasons).

5.1.2 Methodological issues

Detailed methodologies for emissions from solvents and other product use are not provided in the IPCC revised guidelines (IPCC, 1996). Two basic approaches for estimating emissions: consumption and production-based estimates are documented. The IPCC guidelines note that for many applications of solvents, the end uses are too small-scale, diverse and dispersed to be tracked directly. Therefore, emission estimates are generally based on total consumption and an assumption that once these products are sold to end users, they are applied and emissions produced relatively rapidly. For most surface coating and general solvent use, this approach is recommended. The New Zealand inventory estimates solvent emissions with a consumption-based approach. Information is obtained by an industry (CRL Energy Ltd, 2006a). Worksheets for the solvents and other products sector are included in Annex 8.

Emission factors are developed based on the likely final release of NMVOC to the atmosphere per unit of product consumed. The emission factors are applied to sales data for the specific solvent or paint products. The subcategories of solvents and other products specified in the common reporting format are detailed below.

Paint application

Consumption and emissions from paints and thinners are based on information from Nelson (1992) and the Auckland Regional Council (1997). Additional information for 1993 to 1996 was provided by the New Zealand Paint Manufacturers Association.

Degreasing and dry-cleaning

Most dry-cleaners in New Zealand use perchloroethylene and a small number use white spirits. Trichloroethylene has never been used in dry-cleaning but it is used in degreasing, for instance in the leather manufacturing industry. In general, solvent losses from the dry-cleaning industry have reduced substantially as closed circuit machines and refrigerated recovery units are increasingly used. Consumption of perchloroethylene and trichloroethylene are assumed to equal the volume of imports. Import information is supplied by Statistics New Zealand.

Chemical products (manufacturing and processing)

The solvents tetrabutyl urea and alkyl benzene are used in the production of hydrogen peroxide. Emissions of NMVOCs are provided by the sole producer of hydrogen peroxide in New Zealand. The hydrogen-peroxide plant has an on-line, continuous, activated-carbon solvent recovery system. Solvent losses are recorded annually as the difference between input solvent and solvent collected for incineration.

Losses of ethanol (and other minor components such as methanol, acetaldehyde and ethyl acetate) are monitored in the three ethanol plants in New Zealand. Using these values, an emission factor for NMVOC of 6 g/litre has been calculated. Ethanol used for alcoholic beverage production has been reported under food and drink production in the industrial processes sector.

Other – printing ink use

There is one major printing ink company in New Zealand with approximately 50 per cent of the solvent ink market share. The company provided a breakdown on the type of ink used. Approximately 50 per cent of inks used are oil inks (paste inks) which contain high boiling temperature oils. These are evaporated off during “heat setting” but it is understood that the volatiles are generally treated in a solvent burner that minimises emissions. The remaining 50 per cent of inks are liquid of which 60 per cent are solvent inks (the remaining 40 per cent are water based).

Other – aerosols

Approximately 25 million aerosol units are sold in New Zealand each year. Based on the assumptions that the units are fully discharged within two years of purchase, the average propellant charge is 84 grams and 95 per cent are hydrocarbon-based, total NMVOC emissions in 2005 were 2.0 Gg.

Other – domestic and commercial use

This category includes NMVOC emissions from domestic and commercial solvent use in the following areas: household products, toiletries, rubbing compounds, windshield washing fluids, adhesives, polishes and waxes, space deodorants, and laundry detergents and treatments. Emissions for this category are based on a per capita emission factor. The emission factor used is 2.54 kg NMVOC/capita/yr (U.S. EPA, 1985). It is assumed that the emissions rate per capita derived by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) is applicable to the average product use in New Zealand (CRL Energy Ltd, 2006a). Population figures are from the Statistics New Zealand website.

N2O for anaesthesia

Activity data for 2005 were obtained from the sole importer of bulk N2O into New Zealand. The importer supplies its competitor with its requirements so the figure represents full coverage of N2O use in New Zealand. Most of the N2O is used for anaesthesia and the production of Entonox (a half-and-half mixture of nitrous oxide and oxygen for pain relief). There is a very small amount used in motor sports and in scientific analysis.

5.1.3 Uncertainties and time-series consistency

Estimates of uncertainty are based on information provided by industry in the questionnaires and discussions with respondents (CRL Energy Ltd, 2006a). The overall uncertainties are assessed to be:

  • paint application: + 40 per cent

  • degreasing/drycleaning: + 30 per cent

  • chemical product emissions: + 20 per cent

  • printing, aerosols and domestic/commercial use: + 50 per cent, + 20 per cent and + 60 per cent respectively.

  • N2O for anaesthesia: + 10 per cent for annual imports.

5.1.4 Source-specific QA/QC and verification

The consumption data from Auckland Regional Council (1997) and Nelson (Nelson, P, 1992) were compared to import data and discrepancies analysed and clarified by the consultant. There are considerable uncertainties and inconsistencies in applying the United States EPA per capita emission factors based on international experience. However, this is the best option at present as there is generally very little information available on the use of various products and their consequent NMVOC emissions in New Zealand.

5.1.5 Source-specific recalculations

Data in this sector for the 2005 inventory were derived using the same method used for previously reported data.

5.1.6 Source-specific planned improvements

There are no planned improvements for this sector. There are large uncertainties, however the emission levels from the solvents and other products sector are negligible compared with other sectors. In accordance with good practice, New Zealand will continue to focus its inventory development on key source categories (IPCC, 2001).