Skip to main content.

Table 1: Summary of Findings about the Key Urban Design Elements

This table summarises the principal findings from the extensive survey of writings and empirical studies of urban design discussed in this report. It focuses specifically on the elements of urban design about which there are 'useful' findings. Asterisks are used to indicate the quality of the evidence surveyed: *** conclusive, ** strong, * suggestive. Anecdotal findings have been excluded.

  Economic Value Findings Social/Cultural Value Findings Environmental Value Findings

Local Character

  • Attracts highly skilled workers and new economy enterprises.*
  • Assists the promotion and 'branding' of cities and regions*
  • Contributes a competitive edge by providing a 'point of difference.'*
  • Potentially adds a premium to the value of housing.*
  • Reinforces a sense of identity among the residents of a neighbourhood.*
  • Encourages people to become actively involved in managing their neighbourhood.*
  • Offers choice among a wide range of distinct places and experiences.*
  • Supports conservation of non-renewable resources.*

Connectivity

  • Increases viability of local service shops and facilities.**
  • Increases a site or area's accessibility, thereby enhancing land value.**
  • Enhances natural surveillance and security.***
  • Encourages walking and cycling, mainly for non-work trips, leading to health benefits.**
  • Shortens walking distances, encouraging people to walk.**
  • Reduces vehicle emissions through fewer non-work trips.**

Density

  • Provides land savings.***
  • Provides infrastructure and energy savings.**
  • Reduces the economic cost of time allocated to mobility.**
  • Is associated with concentration of knowledge and innovative activity in urban cores.*
  • Is difficult to disentangle from the benefits of mixed use and other factors.**
  • Can contribute to social cohesion.**
  • Tends to promote health through encouraging greater physical activity.**
  • Can be associated with lower crime and greater safety.*
  • Enhances vitality.*
  • Reinforces green space preservation if linked into clustered form.***
  • Reduces run-off from vehicles to water.***
  • Reduces emissions to air and atmosphere.**
  • May conflict with micro/local green space needs.**

Mixed Use

  • Enhances value for those preferring a mixed use neighbourhood.***
  • Utilises parking and transport infrastructure more efficiently.***
  • Increases viability of local service shops and facilities.**
  • Significantly lowers household expenditure on transportation.**
  • Improves access to essential facilities and activities.***
  • Provides convenience.**
  • Encourages walking and cycling, leading to health benefits.**
  • Reduces the need to own a car.**
  • Increases personal safety.**
  • Can enhance social equity.*
  • Reduces car use for local trips (but minor impact on commuting) and hence emissions.***

Adaptability

  • Contributes to economic success over time.**
  • Extends useful economic life by delaying the loss of vitality and functionality.*
  • Increases diversity and duration of use for public space.***
  • Gives ability to resist functional obsolescence.**
  • Supports conservation of non-renewable resources.*

High Quality Public Realm

  • Attracts people and activity, leading to enhanced economic performance.**
  • Public art contributes to enhanced economic activity.**
  • Higher participation in community and cultural activities.***
  • Increased use of public space.***
  • Gives greater sense of personal safety.**
  • Attracts social engagement, pride and commitment to further achievements.**
  • Public art contributes to greater community engagement with public space.**
 

Integrated

Decision-making

  • Co-ordinates physical design and policy in related areas to ensure benefits of good urban design are realised or enhanced.**
  • Encourages people to take advantage of opportunities presented by good urban design.**
  • Provides equity of opportunity for a range of people to benefit from good urban design.*
 

User Participation

  • Makes more effective use of resources.***
  • Offers process cost savings by encouraging user support for positive change.**
  • Improves fit between design and user needs.***
  • Develops user ownership of positive change.**
  • Enhances sense of community.**
  • Enhances sense of well-being.*
  • Legitimises user interests.*
  • Enhances democracy.*