The Minister has received a total of 117 submissions on the NES proposal. The Ministry is now in the process of analysing these submissions.
The majority of submissions were from the forestry industry (27), individuals (26) and territorial authorities (23).
Figure 2 represents the different categories of submitters by their proportion (the number indicates the number of submissions in that category).
* Please note that some local government submissions are officer comments only and do not constitute an official council position.
The submissions were grouped into 4 categories according to their position on the proposal. The nature of the submissions received on the proposal was as follows:
Figure 3 shows the breakdown of submissions by their position (the number indicates the number of submissions in that category).
Electronic copies of all submissions are available to download from the table below.
Table 1: Individual submissions on the proposed NES (Please note that submissions 8, 36 and 56 were withdrawn from the process at the request of the submitter)
| |
Submitter |
Position |
| 1 |
Otago Regional Council (PDF, 614 KB) |
Opposition |
| 2 |
Taupo District Council (PDF, 810 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 3 |
Ruapehu District Council (PDF, 894 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 4 |
Environment Southland (PDF, 374 KB) |
Opposition |
| 5 |
South Waikato District Council (PDF, 1.63 MB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 6 |
Bay of Plenty Regional Council (PDF, 266 KB) |
Opposition |
| 7 |
Vector Limited (PDF, 1.06 MB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 9 |
Environs Holdings Limited (PDF, 2.74 MB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 10 |
Western Bay of Plenty District Council (PDF, 162 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 11 |
Queenstown Lakes District Council (PDF, 163 KB) |
Opposition |
| 12 |
Nick Ledgard (PDF, 430 KB) |
Opposition |
| 13 |
Peter Houston (PDF, 259 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 14 |
Southland District Council (PDF, 46 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 15 |
Auckland Regional Council (PDF, 4.16 MB) |
Opposition |
| 16 |
Gisborne District Council (PDF, 2.31 MB) |
Opposition |
| 17 |
L.F. Carr (PDF, 924 KB) |
Not stated |
| 18 |
Ngai Te Rangi (PDF, 119 KB) |
Not stated |
| 19 |
Jim Paterson (PDF, 86 KB) |
Not stated |
| 20 |
NZ Farm Forestry Association (Hawke's Bay branch) (PDF, 9 KB) |
Opposition |
| 21 |
Royal NZ Forest and Bird Protection Society (Eastern Bay of Plenty branch) (PDF, 164 KB) |
Opposition |
| 22 |
Wade Doak (PDF, 114 KB) |
Not stated |
| 23 |
I B Brickell (PDF, 13 KB) |
Not stated |
| 24 |
Rien Visser (PDF, 235 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 25 |
Paul Baker (PDF, 82 KB) |
Opposition |
| 26 |
Southern Forestry Limited (PDF, 169 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 27 |
Ruapehu Federated Farmers (PDF, 40 KB) |
Opposition |
| Ruapehu Federated Farmers (PDF, 54 KB) |
| Ruapehu Federated Farmers (PDF, 622 KB) |
| 28 |
Wellington Recreational Marine Fishers Association (PDF, 199 KB) |
Opposition |
| Wellington Recreational Marine Fishers Association (PDF, 90.79 KB) |
| 29 |
NZ Farm Forestry Association (Wellington Branch) (PDF, 83 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 30 |
Kerry Borkin and Dr. Stuart Parsons (PDF, 3.54 MB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 31 |
Tomorrow's Forests Limited (PDF, 196 KB) |
Opposition |
| 32 |
NZ Council of Fish and Game (PDF, 98 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 33 |
Northland Regional Council (PDF, 37 KB) |
Opposition |
| 34 |
Annie Carmichael (PDF, 11 KB) |
Not stated |
| 35 |
Simon Fairbrother (PDF, 168 KB) |
Opposition |
| 37 |
Jim and Audrey Walker (PDF, 12 KB) |
Opposition |
| 38 |
Juken New Zealand Limited (PDF, 1.29 MB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 39 |
Timberlands Limited (PDF, 209 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 40 |
Thames-Coromandel District Council (PDF, 3.51 MB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 41 |
Kaipara District Council (PDF, 16 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 42 |
John Lekner (PDF, 2.89 MB) |
Not stated |
| 43 |
Pan Pac Forest Product Forests Limited (PDF, 154 KB) |
Opposition |
| 44 |
Nga Uri o te Ngahere Trust (PDF, 75 KB) |
Opposition |
| 45 |
NZ Farm Forestry Association (PDF, 110 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 46 |
Greater Wellington Regional Council (PDF, 111 KB) |
Not stated |
| 47 |
Darryl and Nicky King (PDF, 120 KB) |
Support |
| 48 |
Environment Waikato (PDF, 2.67 MB) |
Opposition |
| 49 |
Peter Handford (PDF, 51 KB) |
Opposition |
| 50 |
Rayonier New Zealand Ltd/Matariki Forests (PDF, 2.67 MB) |
Supports conditionally |
| Rayonier New Zealand Ltd/Matariki Forests (PDF, 2.99 MB) |
| 51 |
Royal NZ Forest and Bird Protection Society (Tauranga Branch) (PDF, 9 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 52 |
Hastings District Council (PDF, 49 KB) |
Opposition |
| 53 |
Forest and Bird (head office) (PDF, 256 KB) |
Opposition |
| 54 |
Geoff Gover (PDF, 248 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 55 |
Hamish Kendal & Meg Graeme (PDF, 561 KB) |
Opposition |
| 57 |
Wairoa District Council (PDF, 245 KB) |
Opposition |
| 58 |
Davie, Lovell-Smith Ltd (PDF, 144 KB) |
Opposition |
| 59 |
PF Olsen Ltd (Nelson branch) (PDF, 54 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 60 |
Far North District Council (PDF, 605 KB) |
Not stated |
| 61 |
Northpower Limited (PDF, 532 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 62 |
Blakely Pacific Ltd (PDF, 247 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 63 |
Rotorua District Council (PDF, 162 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 64 |
Dunedin City Council (PDF, 56 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| Dunedin City Council (PDF, 104 KB) |
| 65 |
Local Government NZ (PDF, 519 KB) |
Opposition |
| 66 |
Nelson Management Limited (PDF, 191 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| Nelson Management Limited (PDF, 113 KB) |
| Nelson Management Limited (PDF, 595 KB) |
| 67 |
Taranaki Regional Council (PDF, 94 KB) |
Opposition |
| 68 |
Waytemore Forests Limited (PDF, 1.77 MB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 69 |
Central Hawke's Bay District Council (PDF, 9 KB) |
Not stated |
| 70 |
City Forests Ltd (PDF, 415 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 71 |
Kapiti Coast District Council (PDF, 266 KB) |
Opposition |
| 72 |
Marieke Lettink (PDF, 999 KB) |
Opposition |
| 73 |
Christchurch City Council (PDF, 14.3 MB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 74 |
Waimakariri District Council (PDF, 35 KB) |
Opposition |
| 75 |
Wellington City Council (PDF, 268 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 76 |
Forest Owners Association (PDF, 198 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 77 |
NZ Historic Places Trust (PDF, 5.66 MB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 78 |
Southern Wood Council (PDF, 553 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 79 |
Marlborough District Council (PDF, 17 KB) |
Opposition |
| 80 |
Hawke's Bay Regional Council (PDF, 321 KB) |
Opposition |
| 81 |
Electricity Networks Association (PDF, 27 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 82 |
Ann Nicholas (PDF, 481 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 83 |
Landcare Research NZ (PDF, 6.36 MB) |
Support |
| 84 |
NZ Farm Forestry Association Inc (PDF, 51 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 85 |
Resource Management Law Association (PDF, 122 KB) |
Not stated |
| 86 |
Environmental Defence Society (PDF, 75 KB) |
Not stated |
| 87 |
Scion (PDF, 189 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 88 |
Wenita Forest Products (PDF, 138 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 89 |
Tasman District Council (PDF, 1.12 MB) |
Opposition |
| 90 |
West Coast Regional Council (PDF, 31 KB) |
Not stated |
| 91 |
Horizons Regional Council (PDF, 109 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 92 |
Mary Redmayne (PDF, 923 KB) |
Opposition |
| 93 |
NZ Forest Managers Ltd (PDF, 232 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 94 |
Electricity Engineers Association (PDF, 57 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 95 |
Federated Farmers (PDF, 121 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 96 |
New Zealand Anglican Church Pension Board (PDF, 35 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 97 |
PF Olsen Ltd (PDF, 863 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 98 |
NZ Wind Energy Association (PDF, 40 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 99 |
Earnslaw One Limited North Island (PDF, 2.61 MB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 100 |
Myles Pollard (PDF, 357 KB) |
Opposition |
| 101 |
ECO (PDF, 322 KB) |
Opposition |
| 102 |
Watercare Services Limited (PDF, 1.09 MB) |
Not stated |
| 103 |
Gibbons Holdings Limited (PDF, 455 KB) |
Opposition |
| 104 |
Palmerston North City Council (PDF, 697 KB) |
Opposition |
| 105 |
Eastland Wood Council (PDF, 118 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 106 |
Catherine Delahunty (PDF, 203 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 107 |
Southwood Export Limited (PDF, 39 KB) |
Opposition |
| 108 |
IPENZ (PDF, 173 KB) |
Opposition |
| 109 |
Hancock Forest Management (PDF, 586 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 110 |
Rowan Family Trust (PDF, 43 KB) |
Not stated |
| 111 |
Andrew Hocken (PDF, 33 KB) |
Support |
| 112 |
NZ Institute of Forestry (PDF, 125 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 113 |
Powerco (PDF, 1.42 MB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 114 |
Marlborough Forest Industry Association (PDF, 53 KB) |
Not stated |
| 115 |
Selwyn District Council (PDF, 5.43 MB) |
Opposition |
| 116 |
Private individual (PDF, 851 KB) |
Not stated |
| Private individual (PDF, 3.08 MB) |
| 117 |
Hurunui District Council (PDF, 149 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 118 |
Ngati Koata Trust Board (PDF, 79 KB) |
Not stated |
| 119 |
Clutha District Council (PDF, 377 KB) |
Supports conditionally |
| 120 |
Tainui (PDF, 55 KB) |
Not stated |