Skip to main content.

Proposed National Environmental Standard for Plantation Forestry

Submissions

The Minister has received a total of 117 submissions on the NES proposal. The Ministry is now in the process of analysing these submissions.

The majority of submissions were from the forestry industry (27), individuals (26) and territorial authorities (23).

Figure 2 represents the different categories of submitters by their proportion (the number indicates the number of submissions in that category).

Figure 2: Proportions of submissions, by category

Figure 2: Proportions of submissions, by category

The pie chart shows the number and proportion of total submissions, by category

  Number Proportion of total submissions
Forestry Industry 27 23%
Individual 26 22%
Territorial Authorities 23 19%
Regional Councils 11 9%
Other industry 9 8%
NGO 9 8%
Iwi 5 4%
Unitary Authority 3 3%
CRI 2 2%
Crown entity 1 1%
Other 1 1%
TOTALS 117 100%

* Please note that some local government submissions are officer comments only and do not constitute an official council position.

The submissions were grouped into 4 categories according to their position on the proposal. The nature of the submissions received on the proposal was as follows:

  1. Support – clear support was indicated for the proposed NES
  2. Supports conditionally – support was indicated for an NES, but more than minor changes to the proposal were requested
  3. Opposition – clear opposition to the proposed NES was stated
  4. Not stated – no clear statement of support or opposition was given, and this could not be determined from the content of the submission

Figure 3 shows the breakdown of submissions by their position (the number indicates the number of submissions in that category).

Figure 3: Breakdown of submissions, by position

Figure 3: Breakdown of submissions, by position

The pie chart shows the number and proportion of submissions by the position taken.

  Number of submissions Proportion of total
Support 3 3%
Supports conditionally 54 46%
Opposition 41 35%
Not stated 19 16%
TOTALS 117 100%

Electronic copies of all submissions are available to download from the table below.

Table 1: Individual submissions on the proposed NES (Please note that submissions 8, 36 and 56 were withdrawn from the process at the request of the submitter)

  Submitter Position
1 Otago Regional Council (PDF, 614 KB) Opposition
2 Taupo District Council (PDF, 810 KB) Supports conditionally
3 Ruapehu District Council (PDF, 894 KB) Supports conditionally
4 Environment Southland (PDF, 374 KB) Opposition
5 South Waikato District Council (PDF, 1.63 MB) Supports conditionally
6 Bay of Plenty Regional Council (PDF, 266 KB) Opposition
7 Vector Limited (PDF, 1.06 MB) Supports conditionally
9 Environs Holdings Limited (PDF, 2.74 MB) Supports conditionally
10 Western Bay of Plenty District Council (PDF, 162 KB) Supports conditionally
11 Queenstown Lakes District Council (PDF, 163 KB) Opposition
12 Nick Ledgard (PDF, 430 KB) Opposition
13 Peter Houston (PDF, 259 KB) Supports conditionally
14 Southland District Council (PDF, 46 KB) Supports conditionally
15 Auckland Regional Council (PDF, 4.16 MB) Opposition
16 Gisborne District Council (PDF, 2.31 MB) Opposition
17 L.F. Carr (PDF, 924 KB) Not stated
18 Ngai Te Rangi (PDF, 119 KB) Not stated
19 Jim Paterson (PDF, 86 KB) Not stated
20 NZ Farm Forestry Association (Hawke's Bay branch) (PDF, 9 KB) Opposition
21 Royal NZ Forest and Bird Protection Society (Eastern Bay of Plenty branch) (PDF, 164 KB) Opposition
22 Wade Doak (PDF, 114 KB) Not stated
23 I B Brickell (PDF, 13 KB) Not stated
24 Rien Visser (PDF, 235 KB) Supports conditionally
25 Paul Baker (PDF, 82 KB) Opposition
26 Southern Forestry Limited (PDF, 169 KB) Supports conditionally
27 Ruapehu Federated Farmers (PDF, 40 KB) Opposition
Ruapehu Federated Farmers (PDF, 54 KB)
Ruapehu Federated Farmers (PDF, 622 KB)
28 Wellington Recreational Marine Fishers Association (PDF, 199 KB) Opposition
Wellington Recreational Marine Fishers Association (PDF, 90.79 KB)
29 NZ Farm Forestry Association (Wellington Branch) (PDF, 83 KB) Supports conditionally
30 Kerry Borkin and Dr. Stuart Parsons (PDF, 3.54 MB) Supports conditionally
31 Tomorrow's Forests Limited (PDF, 196 KB) Opposition
32 NZ Council of Fish and Game (PDF, 98 KB) Supports conditionally
33 Northland Regional Council (PDF, 37 KB) Opposition
34 Annie Carmichael (PDF, 11 KB) Not stated
35 Simon Fairbrother (PDF, 168 KB) Opposition
37 Jim and Audrey Walker (PDF, 12 KB) Opposition
38 Juken New Zealand Limited (PDF, 1.29 MB) Supports conditionally
39 Timberlands Limited (PDF, 209 KB) Supports conditionally
40 Thames-Coromandel District Council (PDF, 3.51 MB) Supports conditionally
41 Kaipara District Council (PDF, 16 KB) Supports conditionally
42 John Lekner (PDF, 2.89 MB) Not stated
43 Pan Pac Forest Product Forests Limited (PDF, 154 KB) Opposition
44 Nga Uri o te Ngahere Trust (PDF, 75 KB) Opposition
45 NZ Farm Forestry Association (PDF, 110 KB) Supports conditionally
46 Greater Wellington Regional Council (PDF, 111 KB) Not stated
47 Darryl and Nicky King (PDF, 120 KB)  Support
48 Environment Waikato (PDF, 2.67 MB) Opposition
49 Peter Handford (PDF, 51 KB) Opposition
50 Rayonier New Zealand Ltd/Matariki Forests (PDF, 2.67 MB) Supports conditionally
Rayonier New Zealand Ltd/Matariki Forests (PDF, 2.99 MB)
51 Royal NZ Forest and Bird Protection Society (Tauranga  Branch) (PDF, 9 KB) Supports conditionally
52 Hastings District Council (PDF, 49 KB) Opposition
53 Forest and Bird (head office) (PDF, 256 KB) Opposition
54 Geoff Gover (PDF, 248 KB) Supports conditionally
55 Hamish Kendal & Meg Graeme (PDF, 561 KB) Opposition
57 Wairoa District Council (PDF, 245 KB) Opposition
58 Davie, Lovell-Smith Ltd (PDF, 144 KB) Opposition
59 PF Olsen Ltd (Nelson branch) (PDF, 54 KB) Supports conditionally
60 Far North District Council (PDF, 605 KB) Not stated
61 Northpower Limited (PDF, 532 KB) Supports conditionally
62 Blakely Pacific Ltd (PDF, 247 KB) Supports conditionally
63 Rotorua District Council (PDF, 162 KB) Supports conditionally
64 Dunedin City Council (PDF, 56 KB) Supports conditionally
Dunedin City Council (PDF, 104 KB)
65 Local Government NZ (PDF, 519 KB) Opposition
66 Nelson Management Limited (PDF, 191 KB)  Supports conditionally
Nelson Management Limited (PDF, 113 KB) 
Nelson Management Limited (PDF, 595 KB) 
67 Taranaki Regional Council (PDF, 94 KB) Opposition
68 Waytemore Forests Limited (PDF, 1.77 MB) Supports conditionally
69 Central Hawke's Bay District Council (PDF, 9 KB) Not stated
70 City Forests Ltd (PDF, 415 KB) Supports conditionally
71 Kapiti Coast District Council (PDF, 266 KB) Opposition
72 Marieke Lettink (PDF, 999 KB) Opposition
73 Christchurch City Council (PDF, 14.3 MB) Supports conditionally
74 Waimakariri District Council (PDF, 35 KB) Opposition
75 Wellington City Council (PDF, 268 KB) Supports conditionally
76 Forest Owners Association (PDF, 198 KB) Supports conditionally
77 NZ Historic Places Trust (PDF, 5.66 MB) Supports conditionally
78 Southern Wood Council (PDF, 553 KB) Supports conditionally
79 Marlborough District Council (PDF, 17 KB) Opposition
80 Hawke's Bay Regional Council (PDF, 321 KB) Opposition
81 Electricity Networks Association (PDF, 27 KB) Supports conditionally
82 Ann Nicholas (PDF, 481 KB) Supports conditionally
83 Landcare Research NZ (PDF, 6.36 MB) Support
84 NZ Farm Forestry Association Inc (PDF, 51 KB) Supports conditionally
85 Resource Management Law Association (PDF, 122 KB)  Not stated
86 Environmental Defence Society (PDF, 75 KB) Not stated
87 Scion (PDF, 189 KB) Supports conditionally
88 Wenita Forest Products (PDF, 138 KB) Supports conditionally
89 Tasman District Council (PDF, 1.12 MB) Opposition
90 West Coast Regional Council (PDF, 31 KB) Not stated
91 Horizons Regional Council (PDF, 109 KB) Supports conditionally
92 Mary Redmayne (PDF, 923 KB) Opposition
93 NZ Forest Managers Ltd (PDF, 232 KB) Supports conditionally
94 Electricity Engineers Association (PDF, 57 KB) Supports conditionally
95 Federated Farmers (PDF, 121 KB) Supports conditionally
96 New Zealand Anglican Church Pension Board (PDF, 35 KB) Supports conditionally
97 PF Olsen Ltd (PDF, 863 KB) Supports conditionally
98 NZ Wind Energy Association (PDF, 40 KB) Supports conditionally
99 Earnslaw One Limited North Island (PDF, 2.61 MB) Supports conditionally
100 Myles Pollard (PDF, 357 KB) Opposition
101 ECO (PDF, 322 KB) Opposition
102 Watercare Services Limited (PDF, 1.09 MB) Not stated
103 Gibbons Holdings Limited (PDF, 455 KB) Opposition
104 Palmerston North City Council (PDF, 697 KB) Opposition
105 Eastland Wood Council (PDF, 118 KB) Supports conditionally
106 Catherine Delahunty (PDF, 203 KB) Supports conditionally
107 Southwood Export Limited (PDF, 39 KB) Opposition
108 IPENZ (PDF, 173 KB) Opposition
109 Hancock Forest Management (PDF, 586 KB) Supports conditionally
110 Rowan Family Trust (PDF, 43 KB) Not stated
111 Andrew Hocken (PDF, 33 KB) Support
112 NZ Institute of Forestry (PDF, 125 KB) Supports conditionally
113 Powerco (PDF, 1.42 MB) Supports conditionally
114 Marlborough Forest Industry Association (PDF, 53 KB) Not stated
115 Selwyn District Council (PDF, 5.43 MB) Opposition
116 Private individual (PDF, 851 KB) Not stated
Private individual (PDF, 3.08 MB)
117 Hurunui District Council (PDF, 149 KB) Supports conditionally
118 Ngati Koata Trust Board (PDF, 79 KB) Not stated
119 Clutha District Council (PDF, 377 KB) Supports conditionally
120 Tainui (PDF, 55 KB) Not stated

Further information

Last updated: 23 May 2011